WE ARE SELECTING THE 6 PHOTOGRAPHERS THAT WILL BE PRESENTED WORLDWIDE

DodhersThe falling soldier: Tales of a civil war by Robert Capa

The falling soldier; Considered as one of the most impressive war photography of all time, in addition to the most symbolic, widespread, studied and discussed of the Spanish Civil War.
TANYA AKKARI TANYA AKKARI18624 min

The falling soldier; Considered as one of the most impressive war photography of all time, in addition to the most symbolic, widespread, studied and discussed of the Spanish Civil War. Despite being considered a masterpiece, the shadow of doubt questions its authenticity and the controversy has been following it since its publication.

Anyone in the photography trade has seen this picture before, and most likely, those who are not have also seen or heard of it; originally titled as ‘Death of a Loyalist Soldier’, although it’s colloquially known as ‘The Falling Soldier’. What is perhaps less well-known for many, is that it contains a complex and controversial story.

The falling soldier | 1936 | Robert capa | Image Source: Wikipedia

It’s dated from September 5, 1936 and is located in the town of Cerro Muriano in Córdoba. The Hungarian photographer whose real name was Endre Friedmann, was accompanying a group of anarchist soldiers on a seemingly quiet day. Together, they went out in the surroundings of a Cordovan town, to simulate races and jumps between the ravines. Everything went smoothly until the shots of the national side began. The photograph was published in the French magazine Vu on September 23rd of the same year.

In the photograph you can see the Republican soldier Federico Borrell García (the apparent identity of the protagonist), who seems to fall sideways to the ground, while one of his hands holds a rifle that slightly escapes the frame.

The image raised doubts about its authenticity a few days after its publication and is still being questioned today. When it was first shown in the French magazine, it was accompanied by another photograph, taken in the same place, with the same frame and almost at the same time (because of the position of the clouds) of another militiaman who was also falling down, which made many people think that it could be a montage.

Although the original negative has never appeared, it seems that the photograph was taken with a small, lightweight Leica III G of a 35mm negative, which provides a landscape framing of the image. 

Robert Capa | Image Source: Wikipedia

The problem for the photographer was that in order to move to the next negative, he had to take the camera out of his eye, rewind the film, reframe and shoot again. This meant that a few seconds were lost between shots. If the photographer was able to capture not one but two militiamen killed at the very moment of their death, it would be a great coincidence, although not impossible.

The legendary photograph has brought experts from all over the world to bear on Capa’s entire story: the date, the place, the identity of the dead militiaman and, above all, his veracity. One of the first to question the photo was journalist Phillip Knightley, who in 1975 claimed that it was a montage. In his argument he used the little war activity of those days and that Capa had gone out to do a photo session for the militia. There was no doubt in his mind that Borrell’s image was a pose.

Robert Capa was never too eager to talk about that moment. Apparently, Borrell’s death was so shocking to him that it stuck in his memory, and he resented being asked about it. What he did say in the interview granted in 1937 to the New York World-Telegram (the only time he publicly spoke about the picture) is that “no tricks are necessary to take pictures in Spain. You don’t have to pose your camera. The pictures are there, and you just take them. The truth is the best, the best propaganda.”

Inspecting the original negative would have been of great help, but the official version was that it was not preserved, which was not unusual in those days. However, in 2008, the negatives that Capa had lost in 1939 when he fled France for the United States were made public. 

Image Source: Wikipedia

They were 156 photographic reels belonging to Gerda Taro, David Seymour and Robert Capa. About 4,500 photographs that had been found in Mexico in 1995. When examining them, several images of the Spanish Civil War were found, some of them taken on September 5, and that showed that the photo had not been taken where it was said, but in the town of Espejo, about 55 kilometers from Cerro Muriano.

Certainly, regardless of the veracity of the picture, it is a symbol against war. It awakens an anti-war feeling by showing the stark and harsh realities that civilians who remain in their homes are unaware of.



Legal Note: The photographer attest that have full authorization to give consent to the publication of these photos or project and have the authorization and permissions of third parties. Guarantees that you have all the necessary communications of property and you have obtained all the necessary authorizations for any property, buildings, architecture, structures or sculptures appearing in your photographs.

TANYA AKKARI

TANYA AKKARI

Having studied International Relations, there’s a present passion for different cultures, people and history which gives rise to an interest in learning and writing about all those subjects.

https://www.dodho.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/PH5.jpg

Get instant access to over 120 in-depth tutorials for all skill levels, the ability to stream anywhere from any mobile device, and access to our library.

https://www.dodho.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Dodho.jpg
Share your most best images in this photo contest in collaboration with ViewBug. A community that hosts over 40 photo contests and challenges.
300x250

With ON1 Photo RAW you get the professional photo editing tools every photographer needs to get professional results while keeping your workflow.

https://www.dodho.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Landscape-and-Nature-dPS-Photography-Course-300x250-1.jpg

Landscape & nature photography is one of the most challenging genres and disciplines to learn, and the costs of getting it wrong can be disappointing

Magazine

CALL FOR ENTRIES #15

DEADLINE FOR ENTRIES | MONDAY, NOVEMBER 30, 2020

AN AMAZING PROMOTIONAL TOOL DESIGNED TO EXPOSE YOUR WORK WORLDWIDE

PHOTO BY © RYOTARO HORIIUCHI | JAPAN | ISSUE #14

Solo Exhibition

PHOTO CONTEST

DEADLINE FOR ENTRIES: SUNDAY, NOVEMBER 15, 2020

EACH MONTH, THE MOST VALUED PROJECT WILL RECEIVE AN INDIVIDUAL EXHIBITION IN OUR GALLERY

PHOTO BY © JOXE INAZIO KUESTA

LATEST STORIES
X
stay in touch
Join our mailing list and we'll keep you up to date with all the latest stories, opportunities, calls and more.
We never share your data with 3rd parties. Your details will be held securely, we won't share them with anyone else and of course you may unsubscribe at any time. You can read our Privacy Policy here
We’d love to
Submission
Dodho Magazine accepts submissions from emerging and professional photographers from around the world.
Their projects can be published among the best photographers and be viewed by the best professionals in the industry and thousands of photography enthusiasts. Dodho magazine reserves the right to accept or reject any submitted project. Due to the large number of presentations received daily and the need to treat them with the greatest respect and the time necessary for a correct interpretation our average response time is around 5/10 business days in the case of being accepted.
- Between 10/30 images of your best images, in case your project contains a greater number of images which are part of the same indivisible body of work will also be accepted. You must send the images in jpg format to 1200px and 72dpi and quality 9. (No borders or watermarks)
- A short biography along with your photograph. (It must be written in the third person)
- Title and full text of the project with a minimum length of 300 words. (Texts with lesser number of words will not be accepted)
This is the information you need to start preparing your project for its presentation
To send it, you must compress the folder in .ZIP format and use our Wetransfer channel specially dedicated to the reception of works. Links or projects in PDF format will not be accepted. All presentations are carefully reviewed based on their content and final quality of the project or portfolio. If your work is selected for publication in the online version, it will be communicated to you via email and subsequently it will be published.
Issue #14 | September 2020
Current Issue
Vicky Martin
Ryotaro Horiuchi
Susanne Mildeelberg
Diego Bardone
Nicky Hamilton
Alain Schroeder
Printed on 80# matte paper 22x28cm | 100 Pages
Showroom
September 7 to October 31, 2020
Julia Fullerton-Batten
LOOKING OUT FROM WITHIN
Get in touch
How can we help? Got an idea or something you'd like share? Please use the adjacent form, or contact contact@dodho.com
Thank You. We will contact you as soon as possible.
Dodho Magazine is pleased to announce the new call for the photographers selection from all over the world that will be presented in an exceptional edition.
Deadline: Monday, November 30, 2020
Photo by ©Ryotaro Horiuchi | Japan | Issue#14
Dodho Magazine is pleased to announce the new call for the photographers selection from all over the world that will be presented in an exceptional edition.
Deadline: Monday, November 30, 2020
Photo by ©Ryotaro Horiuchi | Japan | Issue#14
CALL
FOR ENTRIES
Dodho Magazine is pleased to announce the new call for the photographers selection from all over the world that will be presented in an exceptional edition.
Are you ready?
Deadline: Monday, November 30, 2020
Contact
How can we help? Got an idea or something you'd like share? Please use the adjacent form, or contact contact@dodho.com
Thank You. We will contact you as soon as possible.
Submission
Dodho Magazine accepts submissions from emerging and professional photographers from around the world.
Their projects can be published among the best photographers and be viewed by the best professionals in the industry and thousands of photography enthusiasts. Dodho magazine reserves the right to accept or reject any submitted project. Due to the large number of presentations received daily and the need to treat them with the greatest respect and the time necessary for a correct interpretation our average response time is around 5/10 business days in the case of being accepted. This is the information you need to start preparing your project for its presentation.
To send it, you must compress the folder in .ZIP format and use our Wetransfer channel specially dedicated to the reception of works. Links or projects in PDF format will not be accepted. All presentations are carefully reviewed based on their content and final quality of the project or portfolio. If your work is selected for publication in the online version, it will be communicated to you via email and subsequently it will be published.