AI in Visual Arts: Photography or ‘Promptography’?

The “photographic language” has evolved over time, moving ever further away from photography and, at the same time, it has fed back into the concept of photography in such a way that no one knows how to distinguish where one concept begins and the other ends. The images obtained using AI are intended to further expand the concept of photographic language

From the image on the right to the image on the left, only 7 months have passed. This infinitesimal time has been long enough to contain a Copernican revolution in the world of visual arts.

The very rapid evolution and consolidation of Artificial Intelligence as a tool for creating images has caused a schism in the world of photography, just when it seemed that the last wounds of the previous schism were finally healing, when digital photography and Photoshop broke out.

Schism in seven months

When Jason Allen (a hitherto unknown illustrator) won the Colorado State Art Fair in September last year with the image “théâtre d’opéra spatial” (the one on the right on the cover) created using Midjourney, they jumped the first alarms; many people in the photographic environment got very nervous and many others suddenly found a new tool to put their own imagination at the service of.

When, in April of this year, with a theatrical act of the best Neapolitan comedy, during the Sony Photography Award ceremony, the German photographer Boris Eldagsen revealed that the image with which he had won the award (the one on the left in the cover) he had done it using artificial intelligence tools, the perfect storm came to pass and now everyone is positioned for or against the issue of “artificial intelligence in visual art”. I ask myself: with so many photographers giving their opinions on the subject, suddenly everyone has forgotten that, in life, as in photography, there are not only white and black, but rather that there are an infinity of intermediate gray tones?

Doubt is a wise approach…

Before delving into the subject, allow me to make a small digression about the image of Eldagsen. Regardless of how it is made, it does not seem to me an image worthy of winning such a prestigious award. Technically, it has flaws, I think they are quite obvious, which on the one hand, reveal the limited mastery of the author of the tools based on artificial intelligence and on the other hand make me think that everything that has happened has been a “staging” orchestrated between the author of the image and organization of the award… Have you noticed the hands in the foreground? The one on the left looks more like an “Edward Scissorhands” hand and the nail on the index finger, a tiger’s claw… and what about the hand on the right? it doesn’t look human, does it? What were the award judges thinking when they analyzed this image? How can an image with such crude imperfections win the absolute prize in such a prestigious contest? …something leads me to think that everything has been premeditated to use the media amplification of this award and thus forcefully send a clear message to the artistic-photographic environment, labeling as cheaters those who “try to sneak” images made using artificial intelligence in photographic contests.

The solution would be very easy, and it would prevent us from further expanding this schism and, incidentally, recovering a minimum of balance in the “judgments” that are now made on visual works made by using artificial intelligence support. They should allow these images to compete in a separate category or offer specific competitions for these types of images. However, it would only be a temporary solution because, in the long term, those who today assume the role of “templars” of pure photography, will have to abdicate and assume that they will have to include “in the club” who today in day is labeled devil, traitor, counterfeiter, cheater.

Do you remember what photography was at the beginning of the 90s? For those who lived through the digital revolution both in the production of images and in their development, don’t you think it’s reviving something that we have already experienced?

It is not the same…

Some will say “it is not the same”! Because behind the digitization of the photographs there was always the human act (in this case the photographer). I ask: why, in your opinion, behind an image made using artificial intelligence tools this is not so? Who thinks not, it is clear that has never really used AI engines to create an image; may be they typed four keywords to get an image to use it as evidence of their thoughts against AI but they really didn’t go deep into the subject. Others may refute me: “it’s one thing to get up at 4am to arrive in a special place to find the light you want, another thing is to type four words in Midjourney”. Apart from the fact that I defy anyone to type four words in Midjourney and obtain an image suitable for a prestigious contest or simply that stands out from the crowd; I also add that whoever argues for this has a concept of photography that undoubtedly moves away from its essence because they consider it closer to physical sacrifice than to the creative act. Others say: what is created with AI is not real. Real? Who dares to say what real means today and worse still, what real will mean in a few years? If real means “with a root or origin made in the physical dimension”, technically the images created using AI are very real because they are generated thanks to millions and millions of images with a root or origin made in the physical dimension. On the other hand: are we sure that the images generated with AI are less real than other images fully accepted in photographic awards or in the most prestigious photographic social networks, made for example with 3D tools or as a composite of many images? What is the difference between a composite made with stock images and an image generated with AI? Why is an image made with some 3D tool considered a photograph while an image made using an AI tool is not? Some will say: in the composite there is an intention! when I create in 3D I have an intention!….well, in AI generated images too! I’m not saying in all of them, but in many of course yes… the same thing that happens in a composite or in any creative act. Perhaps with this we are closer to get what should really count…

In the very near future, the image itself will count less; the proximity to the physical dimension of reality will unfortunately no longer be a variable that will have a fundamental weight; luckily the content the image conveys will be a fundamental understanding key; the purpose for which the image was created, the story it wants to tell, the sensation it wants to provoke, all this I believe that will count much more.

Photography vs Promptography

In an interview provided after his resignation, Eldagsen differentiated a photograph from a “promptography” (very appealing name!). Photography is something that is obtained from light that causes a reaction on a sensitive surface (an emulsion or a sensor); a “promptography” is obtained by typing a prompt and giving it to a neural network. I remember that twenty years ago, in the same environments that currently act as templars of photographic purity, saying that a digital camera sensor was comparable to the sensitive surface of a chemical emulsion was almost blasphemy to say! To the above I add that, to be consistent with the definition of photography to which we are referring, the owners of the most used photographic social networks, the organizers of photographic contests, the photographic critics should be less hypocritical and be more consistent and coherent. They should exclude in their contests, in their networks, in their reviews any “pseudo-photographic” image made with a 3D tool, any composite that includes non-photographic elements… and what about composites made with stock images?… where do we put the images in which photography is mixed with painting or illustration? Is it a question of photographic preponderance? What is then the % of photography that has to be present in an image? But…an image made with an AI tool, by definition has a clear preponderance of photography! …then this is not the correct argument either…it seems…

Perhaps then the argument is related to the authorship of the images…those who know the AI “backstage” know well that the probability that an image is a copy of one of the millions of millions of images that make up the generative universe is mathematically equal to zero. This can also be affirmed if we apply this same affirmation to any small part of an image created with an AI tool (a hand, a tree, a nose, etc…). So…where is the problem? Could be the copyright? (Copyright and Authorship are very far concepts!)  There have been many sentences in the world and in the artistic field that it cannot be considered that the copyright law is broken if a small part of the created work is the same as another already existing.

If I make a composite or also a simple collage, using photographs purchased or downloaded from an image bank, does anyone dare to comment on its authorship? Some would say: “it is that in this case the artist is what decides which pieces to include and how to make them dialogue with the others”…I guarantee that the same thing happens when a complex “prompt” is created…and I go further…if someone generates 100 images using an AI tool and with these (or with pieces of them) he/she makes a composite… how would this be considered? Would anyone be able to understand that AI is involved? …how much hypocrisy!!!

Photography and Photographic Language

The “photographic language” has evolved over time, moving ever further away from photography and, at the same time, it has fed back into the concept of photography in such a way that no one knows how to distinguish where one concept begins and the other ends. The images obtained using AI are intended to further expand the concept of photographic language. They will also contribute to the definition of “alternative truths” to the “real world”, so much so that the question will not be whether or not it is photography; nor will it be whether or not it is reality. Simply, the question will disappear and each one will decide in which of the different possible realities he/she will want to believe and act accordingly… a total nonsense that entails ethical issues, public order, psychological, etc., etc. To which we will not be prepared because the speed with which these tools progress is exponentially higher than our adaptation times… This is the real problem.

In the meantime, in order for everyone to live in greater harmony, it would be nice to allow creativity made using AI tools to have a place somewhere because whoever produces art in this way has the same right as any photographer who can compete in one of the many Awards that are organized and that flatter the artistic abilities of the authors.

Before closing this article, I wanted to add something more. The AI revolution for the visual market is balanced by another trend very present in the young “digital generation”, that of the return to emulsion and analog cameras. An enormously increasing phenomenon which in my opinion is very significant because it is an important signal that younger generations are asking for slow times dictated by thought, craftsmanship and attachment to tangible reality … I will talk about this in a future article…

Photosatriani

I am a curious of life with idealistic tendencies and a fighter. I believe that shadows are the necessary contrast to enhance the light. I am a lover of nature, of silence and of the inner beauty. My photographic history is quite silent publicly but very rich personally, studded with some great satisfactions such as: gold and silver winner in MUSE Awards 2023 Special Category; Highly Commended in IGPOTY 2022 Wildflowers Landscapes and Breathing Spaces, published photographer in 1X; honorable mention in Pollux Award 2019; commended in IGPOTY 2019 B&W section; highly commended in IGPOTY 2018 Abstract section; selected in 2014 for Descubrimientos PhotoEspaña and in VIPHOTO. Group exhibitions in: Atlántica Colectivas FotoNoviembre 2015 and 2013; selected for the Popular Participation section GetxoPhoto 2020 and 2015; ”PhotoVernissage (San Petersburgo) 2012; DeARTE 2012 y 2013. A set of my images belongs to the funds of Tecnalia company in Bilbao, to the collection of the "Isla de Tenerife" Photography Center and to the Medicos sin Fronteras collection in Madrid. [Website]

More Stories

Old Public Housing In Their Pastel Hue by James Teo

Old Public Housing In Their Pastel Hue by James Teo

Architectural photography got James interested in photography in the first place. Buildings and their intricacies - the lines, shapes and patterns.
Bikini Words

Bikini Words

During the industrial expansion of Korea in the 1970s and 80s, working and housing conditions gave rise to new linguistic developments among the workers.
Interview with Hal Gage; Published in our print edition #10

Interview with Hal Gage; Published in our print edition #10

I think my work touches on the relationship between all of these elements; the imagined, death and the landscape. The theme of death is something which has come about indirectly, as a result of my interest in other ideas such as dystopia, memory and the uncanny. 
https://www.dodho.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/bannerpr.jpg

We invite you to participate in the first edition of the Portrait Photography Awards. Our call is open to any artistic interpretation of portrait photography.

https://www.dodho.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/BAnImage.jpg

ImageRights provides intelligent image search and copyright enforcement services to photo agencies and professional photographers worldwide.

https://www.dodho.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/mono2022.jpg

The best 100 images along with the winning images published in the yearly book “Monochromatic – Best Photographers of 2022”

Call For Entries #24 | After 23 editions and more than 100 published photographers, our print edition has proven to be a simply effective promotional channel.

Jeff Alu ; Between documentary and a semi-dreamlike state

Jeff Alu ; Between documentary and a semi-dreamlike state

My shooting style is very spontaneous. Very rarely do I plan anything out, and it’s the element of surprise and discovery that drives me forward. While I do enjoy traveling distances to obtain my shots,
The mysterious world of Cala Palmera by Mitar Terzic

The mysterious world of Cala Palmera by Mitar Terzic

The key to finding these gaps, where reality is punctured and the other dimension emerges, lies in one's state of mind. Unfortunately, there is no formula or secret to learning how to reach that parallel universe.
Model and photographer; Self-portraits by Fabiola Viviano

Model and photographer; Self-portraits by Fabiola Viviano

A photograph may be able to transmits feelings, emotions, thoughts and even more to communicate to the viewer. In my opinion every person represent its own universe.
Paradise Now by Ryan Koopmans

Paradise Now by Ryan Koopmans

Paradise Now explores how urban fantasies and construction function as expressions of nationalistic ambition, blurring the line between the natural and artificial within the hypermodern city.
Traditional fire-walking ritual; Dancing on Fire by Demetrios Ioannou

Traditional fire-walking ritual; Dancing on Fire by Demetrios Ioannou

On May 21 every year, in some villages in northern Greece, takes place a spectacular traditional fire-walking ritual, called Anastenaria.
New York; Subway by Roman Kruglov

New York; Subway by Roman Kruglov

I loved photography as a child, my grandfather showed me how to measure the light, the F stops and all the basics
Anthropocene by Athena Carey

Anthropocene by Athena Carey

Anthropocene – human traces We were here… In this work I am addressing the imprint that humanity is leaving on planet Earth. Through combustion of fossil fuels (oil, gas, coal, etc), herding and agriculture, mining, water diversion, species extinction, deforestation, etc.
Saskia Boelsums, Sculptor and Photographer

Saskia Boelsums, Sculptor and Photographer

Ever since her art school days, Saskia Boelsums had been fascinated by the many possibilities and results that photography could create. Over the past few years, Saskia has spent more time working with this medium.
Interview with Efrat Sela; Published in our print edition #09

Interview with Efrat Sela; Published in our print edition #09

I would not define this as a religious encounter; I would define it as a meeting between cultures, between different societies. Unfortunately, I have not yet been part of a women's talk after the beach activity.
Documentary photography; Shelter by Aleksandra Lekovic

Documentary photography; Shelter by Aleksandra Lekovic

Photographs were taken during 2014-2015 in an asylum in Belgrade, Serbia. Residents belong to different age groups, corporal and mental competence. Common to all is that they were brought to the borders of existence, some of them are on the boundary between life and death
Wardrobe Snacks by Kelsey Mcclellan

Wardrobe Snacks by Kelsey Mcclellan

Wardrobe Snacks, a series created by Michelle Maguire (art direction and styling) and Kelsey McClellan (photography), a collaborative duo known as Terrence Caviar, was inspired by diners lacking the luxury of being seated at a table.
Women hold up half the sky by Gerard Exupery

Women hold up half the sky by Gerard Exupery

It’s another beautiful day in paradise. Dark, and rainy. It’s one of those days that suggest the beauty of film. F-stop wide open, the darkness and grain, the feeling of an impressionist painting.
The art of photography; Christopher Robert

The art of photography; Christopher Robert

Growing up, I was lucky enough to spend a couple of years driving around Australia with my mum, dad and sister. Naturally, I fell in love with the outdoors and still feel a strong connection with everything this incredible country has to offer.
The atmosphere of a dream.; Somnus by Patrizio Silvi Antonini

The atmosphere of a dream.; Somnus by Patrizio Silvi Antonini

There is a 1922 photograph, taken by Man Ray, portraying the nude of the model-muse-of-artists Kiki de Montparnasse. Her body, which is inclined backwards, is framed—slightly foreshortened—emphasizing the full curve of her thighs.
Sergey Poznansky ; Magic of an “immortal” photography

Sergey Poznansky ; Magic of an “immortal” photography

In our century, in which we are surrouneded by exabytes of glamorous pictures as a demonstration of ostentatious perfection of the binary code, some stubborn people of the past are still seeking for the technologies of the past.
Conceptual Photography; Mind Pop by Nicoletta Cerasomma

Conceptual Photography; Mind Pop by Nicoletta Cerasomma

My project aim to dig the loneliness and difficulties of being in a relationship, mostly when the relationship is essentially at an endpoint.

Featured Stories

The ordinary by Lotta Lemetti

The ordinary by Lotta Lemetti

For me creating still life compositions is a form of self-exploration. The creating process is an intriguing and almost devotional journey through my mind. Through predilections in aesthetic decisions such as subject matter, color and composition the work reflects who I am, where I come from and what I have experienced.
Baikal of wonders by Alina Desyatnichenko

Baikal of wonders by Alina Desyatnichenko

The land of Baikal region in Russia has always been sacred for the local indigenous peoples – buryats. And shamans who could talk to local gods were revered as a hereditary caste of the chosen.
architectural photography of Julia Anna Gospodarou

architectural photography of Julia Anna Gospodarou

Architect and International Award-Winning B&W Fine Art Photographer, Julia lives in Athens and has a passion for both architecture and photography, doing them with the same dedication and joy.
Afromexican healers by Annick Donkers

Afromexican healers by Annick Donkers

At the end of last year my attention was drawn to the coastal region of Guerrero known as Costa Chica, located to the south of Acapulco.
Delhi … where life never stops 
by Victoria Knobloch & Jagdev Singh

Delhi … where life never stops 
by Victoria Knobloch & Jagdev Singh

Monochrome Photoart is a joint venture of the german photographer Victoria Knobloch and the indian photographer Jagdev Singh. Their work highlights the essence of human existence with the same loving eyes yet individualy different.
The departed by Zhou Yulong

The departed by Zhou Yulong

When my grandfather passed away that year, I stood beside him. The weeping people had gone, and there were only the two of us. He lay there as if he were asleep, and I stood in a trance in a dream.
Wiebke Haas ; Fine art equine

Wiebke Haas ; Fine art equine

Wiebke Haas is a dedicated award-winning equine and animal photographer from Germany. Ever since she was a little girl she dreamt of hoof-beats and flying through the fields on a back of a horse.
Vegetable Peddler by Yoshitaka Masuda

Vegetable Peddler by Yoshitaka Masuda

In Japan, baby boomers continue to grow older, and the population 75 years or older has grown to be 13.3% of the total population. 6.1% of these women and 2.7% of these men cannot go out shopping or ask a relative living elsewhere to assist them.
The soul of photography by Maria Svarbova

The soul of photography by Maria Svarbova

I am Maria Svarbova also known as Aria Baró. I am 25 years old woman home based on Slovakia. I have graduated archeology this year. My first artistic attempts falls down back to my early child hood what is later in 2010 transforming in to photography dedication entirely.
Reflecting on Nature by Loreal Prystaj

Reflecting on Nature by Loreal Prystaj

There is no such thing as compromising with nature; we simply abide by how it lives and exist as a part of it. Nature is very relevant to each individual’s well-being, but more so than it is part of us, we are part of it.
Calcio Storico Fiorentino by Marco Ponzianelli

Calcio Storico Fiorentino by Marco Ponzianelli

The Historical Football was born in Florence in the 16th century and it is a combination of soccer, rugby and wrestling world that nowadays is played in historical costumes.
Northern Siberia; Like Last Year’s Snow by Oded Wagenstein

Northern Siberia; Like Last Year’s Snow by Oded Wagenstein

In the remote village of Yar-Sale in Northern Siberia live a group of elderly women. They were once part of a nomadic community of reindeer herders.
Picasso’s Women by Cristina Vatielli

Picasso’s Women by Cristina Vatielli

The project was conceived to reveal the stories of the women who revolved around Pablo Picasso’s life, by strongly influencing the work of the most acclaimed artist of the XX century.
Favelas: the rhythm of change by Albertina d’Urso

Favelas: the rhythm of change by Albertina d’Urso

The favelas of Rio de Janeiro are mostly known for violence and drug trafficking. But, also if those problems still exist, life for most of the inhabitants has nothing to do with that. Favelas are becoming safer and better organized.
The state of emotional destruction; Bandage Portrait by Kai Nagayama

The state of emotional destruction; Bandage Portrait by Kai Nagayama

This series I named Bandage Portraits. It is meant to explore the state of emotional destruction and resilience. It is so easy to be ignorant to your own feelings even though you are aware of them.
Everybody Counts by Erlend Mikael Saeverud

Everybody Counts by Erlend Mikael Saeverud

Erlend wanted to ask him for a portrait, but he didn't dare. This became the inspiration for this project.

Trending Stories

Documentary photography; Ghosts of Helen Keller by Nicolas Landemard

Documentary photography; Ghosts of Helen Keller by Nicolas Landemard

In 1962, the American Arthur Penn made ​​a film entitled " The Miracle Worker ." Adaptation of a book written a few years earlier : The Story of Helen Keller .
Time fragments by Gabor Dvornik

Time fragments by Gabor Dvornik

A hunter to trap those individual moments in life which can be sometimes rare to see and to feel. This means that it is probably time itself with what I am dealing from day to day.
China Dolls by Nathalie Daoust

China Dolls by Nathalie Daoust

In 2006, Nathalie Daoust went to China for an artist residency with the Red Gate Gallery and fell in love with the culture.
Haenyeo; Grandma divers by Alain Schroeder

Haenyeo; Grandma divers by Alain Schroeder

South Korea, Jeju island, known for its characteristic basalt volcanic rock, sits off South Korea. It is the home of the renowned Haenyeo or women of the sea who free dive off the black shores of Jeju harvesting delicacies from the sea.
Art Shay: America’s Visual Diarist by Raju Peddada

Art Shay: America’s Visual Diarist by Raju Peddada

“You are a naughty man!” responded an amused, flirtatious and nude Simone de Beauvoir to Art Shay, who had sneaked from behind the open door and shot a whole strip of her nudes, while she groomed herself in the bathroom.
Portrait Photography; Glass by Laura Pannack

Portrait Photography; Glass by Laura Pannack

This questions how people often object to having their portrait taken and how they react when faced with the situation. I denied my subjects any control over the image taking as I was aware that as photographer’s their awareness and involvement would be much more apparent.
Interview with Ellie Davies; Published in our print edition #07

Interview with Ellie Davies; Published in our print edition #07

The recent print edition is fantastic, you’ve been kind enough to give me seven double-page spreads with a beautiful and comprehensive overview of my most recent series – Fires, 2018.  The paper and print quality are also exceptional, thanks again Dodho Magazine!
The Dance behind the Mask by Pritam Dutta

The Dance behind the Mask by Pritam Dutta

In Purulia Chhau dancers wear large stylised masks while performing and hence the evolving of Chhau Mask making. This dance form is predominantly seen in the states of Odissa, West Bengal and Jharkhand
Multiexpo by Frank Machalowski

Multiexpo by Frank Machalowski

It launched in Berlin, his hometown for 40 years, but then he extended this kind of photography to other citys. For this series he use exclusive analogue film material in both dimensions (35mm and 6x6) and only b&w.
J.W. Fike’s Photographic Survey of the Wild Edible Botanicals of the North American Continent

J.W. Fike’s Photographic Survey of the Wild Edible Botanicals of the North American Continent

Within my system the plant is excavated, arranged in the studio, photographed, then illustrated digitally in such a way as to render the edible parts in color while the remaining parts
Chatting with Nico Chiapperini

Chatting with Nico Chiapperini

When I was eight years old, I took some pictures of fake dinosaurs with my father’s camera, during a school trip. I used two rolls of film and later my dad complained about the waste of money.
What Makes a Great Fine Art Architectural Photograph? by Sharon Tenenbaum

What Makes a Great Fine Art Architectural Photograph? by Sharon Tenenbaum

Every person you ask might have a different answer to that question, however, from my experience, there are a few key factors that are imperative to transforming a just good image to a great one.

Other Stories

stay in touch
Join our mailing list and we'll keep you up to date with all the latest stories, opportunities, calls and more.
We use Sendinblue as our marketing platform. By Clicking below to submit this form, you acknowledge that the information you provided will be transferred to Sendinblue for processing in accordance with their terms of use
We’d love to
Thank you for subscribing!
Submission
Dodho Magazine accepts submissions from emerging and professional photographers from around the world.
Their projects can be published among the best photographers and be viewed by the best professionals in the industry and thousands of photography enthusiasts. Dodho magazine reserves the right to accept or reject any submitted project. Due to the large number of presentations received daily and the need to treat them with the greatest respect and the time necessary for a correct interpretation our average response time is around 5/10 business days in the case of being accepted.
- Between 10/30 images of your best images, in case your project contains a greater number of images which are part of the same indivisible body of work will also be accepted. You must send the images in jpg format to 1200px and 72dpi and quality 9. (No borders or watermarks)
- A short biography along with your photograph. (It must be written in the third person)
- Title and full text of the project with a minimum length of 300 words. (Texts with lesser number of words will not be accepted)
This is the information you need to start preparing your project for its presentation
To send it, you must compress the folder in .ZIP format and use our Wetransfer channel specially dedicated to the reception of works. Links or projects in PDF format will not be accepted. All presentations are carefully reviewed based on their content and final quality of the project or portfolio. If your work is selected for publication in the online version, it will be communicated to you via email and subsequently it will be published.
Contact
How can we help? Got an idea or something you'd like share? Please use the adjacent form, or contact contact@dodho.com
Thank You. We will contact you as soon as possible.
Submission
Dodho Magazine accepts submissions from emerging and professional photographers from around the world.
Their projects can be published among the best photographers and be viewed by the best professionals in the industry and thousands of photography enthusiasts. Dodho magazine reserves the right to accept or reject any submitted project. Due to the large number of presentations received daily and the need to treat them with the greatest respect and the time necessary for a correct interpretation our average response time is around 5/10 business days in the case of being accepted. This is the information you need to start preparing your project for its presentation.
To send it, you must compress the folder in .ZIP format and use our Wetransfer channel specially dedicated to the reception of works. Links or projects in PDF format will not be accepted. All presentations are carefully reviewed based on their content and final quality of the project or portfolio. If your work is selected for publication in the online version, it will be communicated to you via email and subsequently it will be published.
Get in Touch
How can we help? Got an idea or something you'd like share? Please use the adjacent form, or contact contact@dodho.com
Thank You. We will contact you as soon as possible.